Fethu'l Bârî ve Umdetü'l-Kârî'nin Metin Tahlili Açısından İncelenmesi

(Examining the Fethu’l-Bârî and ‘Umdetü'l-Kârî in terms of Text Analyses)


Explanations of ahadith (sharh) significantly include the activities of both “understanding” and “interpretation”. However, the works that have academically researched and systematized these activities are rare. In ahadith literature, Ibn Hajar’s and Ayni’s explanations are remarkable in this particular. The question as to how the interpreters performed the activities of understanding and interpreting the ahadith has been a source of interest for many years. In this study, two explanations by Bukhari, one belonging to Ibn Hajar and one to Ayni, members of different sects at the same period, are compared. In this survey it is also examined whether there was ever any neglect of understanding the ahadith in the past. The possibilities of diversity in commentary are also demonstrated for the reader.

In this work, the main aim is to examine Fethu’l-Bârî and ‘Umdetü'l-kârî’s methods in terms of text analysis. While carrying out this task the following question was paramount: What are both analyses based on? In understanding the texts, was importance given only to the words or did they also take into account the social and historical backgrounds? Was there a sufficient use of rhetoric (balaghat)? Did they consider the Qur’an when trying to understand a hadith? Were they able to draw attention to the reasons of the discourse and the wisdom of the hadith? What kind of method did they use if there was a conflict between two hadiths or between a hadith and a verse from the Qur’an itself? Did they interpret the ahadith as sources of information and civilization? Did the text analyses take on an irregular or systematic form? How much did their sects affect them when they were interpreting the hadiths? Did they make a criticism of the hadith text? Finally, was their work descriptive or prescriptive.


Ankara / ISAM Publications & TDV Publications / 2020

ISBN / Pages

978-625-7205-64-1 / 363 p.

Click for title page, contents, and preface.

Click to buy






    Articles on Theology
    On-going Theology Theses
    Articles in Ottoman Turkish
    Treatises in Ottoman Turkish
    Electronic Resources
    Links             Membership







Arkadaşına Gönder

           TDV Encyclopedia of Islam
           Academic Researches
           Editions and Translations
           PhD Theses
              - INTRODUCTION TO THE EPIST...
              - Fıkıh Usulünde Mütekellim...
              - Hz. Peygamber Döneminde Ç...
              - Azerbaycan’da Din: Sovyet...
              - Şem'î Efendi ve Mesnevî Ş...
              - Sebepleri ve Sonuçları Aç...
              - The Role of Poetry in the...
              - Zeydiyye-Mu'tezile Etkileşimi Zeyd b. Ali'den Kasım er-Ressî'nin Ölümüne Kadar">...
              - Fethu'l Bârî ve Umdetü'l-Kârî'nin Metin Tahlili Açısından İncelenmesi">...
              - HADİS RİVAYETİNDE RÂVİ TA...
              - İmam Şâfiî'nin Kıyas Anlayışı">...
              - İmâmiyye Şîası’nın Oluşumu">...
              - Nahivciler ile Mantıkçılar Arasındaki Tartışmalar">...
              - Fıkhî Açıdan Günümüz Para Mübadelesi İşlemleri">...
              - Memlükler Döneminde Vezirlik (The Vizierate in the Mamlûk Period) ">...
           Qadi Registers
           Conference and Symposium Proceedings
           Prestige Books
           Popular Books
           Critical Manuscript Editions
           ISAM Publications - Books